Teleforum

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit (Judges Kayatta, Selya and retired Justice Souter) ruled on September 15 that the National Labor Relations Board was correct as a matter of law in holding that private sector unions may never charge dissenting nonmembers for their lobbying activity. The private sector union in this case, United Nurses & Allied Professionals, lobbied the Vermont and Rhode Island legislatures on a variety of bills, and argued that no Supreme Court case squarely held lobbying to be nonchargeable to nonmembers in the private sector, and that the NLRB erred in its analysis of the Supreme Court’s line of compulsory dues cases when it held lobbying per se nonchargeable. To reach its decision, the First Circuit analyzed the line of Supreme Court cases that stretches from IAM v. Street (1961) to CWA v. Beck (1988) to Lehnert v. Ferris Faculty Association (1991) to Harris v. Quinn (2014) and ultimately to the decision in Janus v. AFSCME (2018). The First Circuit agreed with the